what size honey super should i go with, regular or medium? i will not be using an extractor, just a big knife - the larger super should yield more honey per frame. the plan is to crush and strain the honey and to have some comb as well...
-steve
http://forum.beemaster.com/index.php/topic,20289.0.html
Quote from: iddee on March 13, 2009, 03:23:11 PM
http://forum.beemaster.com/index.php/topic,20289.0.html
i'll go with mediums.
If you will only be keeping a few hives you could use all deeps if you wanted to. Instead of moving the entire super all at one time you could remove what frames you wanted to, replace, and so on.
Or you could pull half the frames, put them aside and pull the entire box less the 5 frames.
Point being you don't have to remove the entire box with its full weight. With deeps you will have more honey because they hold more.
...JP
It really depends on your back and arms. My back has a really rough time with that top box when it is 4 deeps high. However, if I could run all deeps physically, I would. Just less work at extracting time.
I myself believe this is probably the question that will get the most different answers. It is also the one that there is truely no wrong answer. It is simply a choice of preference. The deeps mean more honey and less equipment. They also mean back breaker if you move an entire box at a time. The mediums mean more honey than the shallow but less than the deep. Mediums can still be heavy if full. Shallows mean less honey and more equipment but easier to carry, load, unload. shallows are also the correct depth for comb honey boxes.
I myself use all 3 and have been told I am nuts but it works great for me. I use deeps for brood, mediums for liquid honey, and shallows for comb honey.
Quotei will not be using an extractor, just a big knife
How do you plan on removing the honey w/o an extractor. I suspect you are not using comb honey if you are asking about the size of the supers.
QuoteI myself use all 3 and have been told I am nuts but it works great for me. I use deeps for brood, mediums for liquid honey, and shallows for comb honey.
I think this is ideal. Why would anyone argue this approach? Deeps make the best hive bodies IMO. The Kim Flotam (spelled wrong) position that using only mediums because then you will have the size on hand if you need an extra super or hive body doesn't hold a lot of weight-w-me. If you run deeps for the hive and need an "emergency" honey super then use a deep (on top of a shallow or medium-w-some honey in the center at least) and remove frames of capped honey instead of the whole 100 lb box.
I would love to do comb honey at some point. How easy would that be compared to extracting! In my area it is looked upon as too "old time" and I doubt it would sell too well. I have my hopes very high for a great harvest/sale so I can write a nice check to the cancer foundation. There is a long time before this can happen but I've been busting my butt to get all the required supplies ready. All that I have left is to frame some foundation and make my extractor. The extractor will be the big challenge.
You can do comb honey in any size frame. Its a matter of using the square comb cutter and any left over pieces you use for chunk honey.
Quote from: challenger on March 15, 2009, 11:03:40 AM
Quotei will not be using an extractor, just a big knife
How do you plan on removing the honey w/o an extractor. I suspect you are not using comb honey if you are asking about the size of the supers.
QuoteI myself use all 3 and have been told I am nuts but it works great for me. I use deeps for brood, mediums for liquid honey, and shallows for comb honey.
I think this is ideal. Why would anyone argue this approach? Deeps make the best hive bodies IMO. The Kim Flotam (spelled wrong) position that using only mediums because then you will have the size on hand if you need an extra super or hive body doesn't hold a lot of weight-w-me. If you run deeps for the hive and need an "emergency" honey super then use a deep (on top of a shallow or medium-w-some honey in the center at least) and remove frames of capped honey instead of the whole 100 lb box.
I would love to do comb honey at some point. How easy would that be compared to extracting! In my area it is looked upon as too "old time" and I doubt it would sell too well. I have my hopes very high for a great harvest/sale so I can write a nice check to the cancer foundation. There is a long time before this can happen but I've been busting my butt to get all the required supplies ready. All that I have left is to frame some foundation and make my extractor. The extractor will be the big challenge.
Your 100% right the sizes have been perfected for optimum use deeps are the best for brood HOWEVER us youg guys must remember that many beeks are a tad older, women, and handicapped..... that said, many times meduims and shallow supers are just fine........
So use the standard langstroth if you can, if not size to suit.....
Personaly at this point in time I like the Illinois Supers, don't need as many or tended to as often as the shallows... if you did a stack of say 3 mediums and 5 shallows.. you would find more working space for the bees in the 3 mediums despite teh fact that 5 shallows are taller.
gmcharlie;
I have found a lot of new people are confused with the meanings of;
Shallow = basicly, used for comb honey
Medium or Illinois or Dadant = honey super, some use for brood also.
Deep = honey or brood
Also the terms;
Super Box = honey storage
Brood Box = well, were the queen and itibity baby bees are found
Bee-Bop
Good point, since I am from Illinois I tend to overlook that description..........Freudian slip??