I have an existing colony of bees that have been living on my property in a old piece of machinery for at least 13 years and is another part of why I decided to keep bees in the first place since they have never been aggressive. There is no good way I know of to get them out without a cutting torch which will obviously not work... So I was pondering when and how to lure a swarm out of the existing colony to add to my growing apiary. Would be nice to be able to do this a few times over the next couple years. Guess I am wondering if this would be a time this could be done or wait for March and April when we see the most swarming here in AZ. We like many are in a summer dearth right now, but our monsoon season has started and with it rain which will stimulate the late summer and fall flow.
You can't really lure them into swarming, but you can lure them into a bait hive.
http://www.bushfarms.com/beesferal.htm#baithives
Thank you, need to spend some more time reading..... :wink:
I didn't say that very well. You can lure a swarm (bees who already decided to leave and swarm) into your bait hive sometimes. You can't incite an established colony to swarm, though. They will swarm when the conditions and time of year set that off. I suppose you could feed incessantly and that might get them to swarm...
Swarm trapping is like fishing...be patient and if you have the resources and know of a few feral hives put out several bait hives.....and it can be a lot of fun ;-)
Quote from: Nugget Shooter on June 30, 2016, 01:54:05 PM
There is no good way I know of to get them out without a cutting torch which will obviously not work... So I was pondering when and how to lure a swarm out of the existing colony to add to my growing apiary. Would be nice to be able to do this a few times over the next couple years.
Look-up 'Hogan Bee Trap' - this technique can either be used to extract the whole colony, queen an' all - or - which is what I think you might be aiming at - it can be used to harvest bees at regular internals, leaving the queen
in situ to keep the numbers up. Seeing as you're in the desert, I don't see any reason why you couldn't feed that feral colony with a little sugar syrup via the Hogan Bee Trap during a dearth.
LJ
https://honey-sun.com/tech-tools/hogans-bee-trap/
This sounds like a perfect job for a trap out.
Is there only one way into this hive or would it bee easy to block all but one entrance?
Jim
Interesting, I will post a photo of where the feral hive is located when I get home from work this afternoon and see what you think, Not sure about being able to cover the entrance or how many entrances there may be.....
I'd leave that very successful hive alone, but do my best to trap the swarms it throws.
Cornell did a study on swarm trapping, and the key points were: a box the size of a ten-frame deep, fifteen feet high, facing south, in the shade, no comb, with five used frames pushed together in the center. That formula has worked well for me.
looks like this....
(https://scontent.xx.fbcdn.net/t31.0-8/13495549_1113408855386619_4030842558412779812_o.jpg)
(https://scontent.xx.fbcdn.net/t31.0-8/13569039_1113408842053287_7202396979989231748_o.jpg)
(https://scontent.xx.fbcdn.net/t31.0-8/13585230_1113408845386620_1074323244780652614_o.jpg)
I'm curious, what is that thing?
Jim
Old band saw.
Hi Jim, as already mentioned it is a saw for cutting pipe etc. pan was an oil bath with oil in tank below, from the early 1900s
Why in the world would you trap it out. Let it cast swarms and collect them. Trapped out one hive... caught swarms... how many???
Thanks to all for your input and once again I have learned and once again left to ponder just the same.
Having now pondered :rolleyes: and having listened to some great input I have once again put my new bee guy enthusiasm on hold and will trap swarms from this hive or at least attempt it this spring. As was mentioned that is a long lived and healthy colony and on top of that there are people and pets living within 10 feet on both sides (row of cabins) with no one being stung I know of making the what I would call "calm". So I will get set up to lure a swarm next spring and see how I do....
Today's project however will be to build a Hogan Trap to have handy since I am now the "Bee Guy" in our small community of Morristown AZ population around 280 folks. I have already added to my bee yard by 2 new colonies and have another to go look at today under an eve.
Thanks once again for the mentoring folks,
Bill
It's amazing how fast you can become the "bee guy" once people find out that you have some bees. :cheesy:
And then you decide your time is worth something and those 10 calls you go last week alone cant all be done "for the good of the bees" and you have you start charging a nominal fee to cover your time and expenses and people get grumpy and ask you "i thought you did this just to save the bees?!?!"
But for the most part its fun to be the "bee guy" :-)
I started out charging for gas and time.... Kind of like saving the bees if they have gas money :cool: Most pest control folks here charge big bucks for bee removal and folks are happy to give me 50 bucks. So far anyway and have done 3, two successful and the other colony decided they didn't like the digs and absconded next day.
If I went for a swarm it would be about saving the bees for me, not just in general. If I had to pay someone to come and get them I would definatly be figuring out how the cost compared to a can of raid.
Just my thoughts
gww
Depends on where they are, I guess. If they're in your house and you kill them, the comb and honey will still be there -- for a while, then it will start dripping through the ceiling or whatever and you'll be paying carpenters to repair your house. How does that compare to bee removal? Makes that can of Raid look pretty expensive to me. But everybody's entitled to make their own mistakes in this world.
I get called for swarms occasionally, and I go get them if they're not too far away. Both for the bees and for me, and simply because it's fun.
I have learned the hard way, though, to ask how high and how large the swarm is, and to insist that they text me a photo. Most of the time those swarms of honeybees turn out to be yellow jacket nests.
Yeah here in rural AZ most folks can not afford to pay an exterminator the 250.00 and up they charge for bee removal so they are happy to pay my gas and time to remove them. I have not been called for a swarm and have had to do cut out of the comb and remove bees. Last one took almost 4 hours to get it done and cleaned up and I feel 50.00 was more than fair and the 2nd one we did in a water box tipped me as well for saving them so much and knowing we would not kill the bees.
Here in AZ with all the media hype about "Killer" bees the removal outfits have jacked their prices way up to almost insanity for folks scared to death of any Honey bees on their property. I am happy to help for a small fee to cover my expenses.... The 3 folks that I have helped out would not have even considered spraying them and were very happy to see the bees safely removed to a new home several miles away.
I don't consider a swarm call the same as a call for a cut out. The swarm if it is hanging on a branch or in a tree may move somewhere unwanted and become a cut out but would be pretty easy to not worry too much about while they are on a tree or bush.
I understand paying for a cut out, I just don't understand anyone paying for a swarm removal. They will remove themselves in three days. I know some who would pay to get swarm calls. I agree with asking about wether it is even honey bees and how high or hard they are to reach but before I payed anyone to come and get a swarm in the bushes I would think about a can of raid if I couldn't wait untill they left.
I totaly agree that a cut out is a different animal.
I put an add on craigs list to try and get calls for a swarm but in all honesty I like the trapping better cause I can work them when it suits me. I would love to get a nice easy low hanging swarm if I get the chance though.
I do think if someone called me about a "swarm" and I didn't want to mess with it that I would just try and give them a name of someone who did and if I couldn't think of anybody I would explain that they will probly leave pretty soon on their own. If they said I will give you $50 bucks to come and get them now, Then ok but I wouldn't ask for it cause I might be playing on fears of someone who didn't know better.
I am probly stepping in it here but that is just my feeling being just a dumb hick in my neck of the woods.
Anyway, don't get me wrong, I am full of good wishes for those who are actually getting out there and doing the deeds. I wish that all goes well for you guys.
gww
Ps I reconize there are no killer bees in my area.
Howdy GWW, and I am a rural AZ, gold prospecting, Harley riding, hick and I hope to get a swarm call one day and just shake them in and go home. For me so far just cut outs. This whole thing of beekeeping is fascinating to me and I also share your feelings about rescuing them when we get the chance. Truth is if someone told me they couldn't afford my help I would likely still go....
nugget
I have an uncle whos dream is to sell out here, live in an rv and stay in arizona and pan gold. I don't know if he will ever do it cause he's had the same dream for 30 year. I do know he has spent a lot of time in arizona vacationing/traveling.
I sold my harley about 15 years ago. Got an atv and just stay home mostly now. Retired and loving it where I am. I haven't got a call yet for a swarm or cut out. I am not really looking hard either but I do help those close to me sometimes and would help others maby if I knew they needed it but don't go out enough to see more then relitives which keep me busy enough.
I feel for those who have to deal with african bees, heck mine are just mutts and they can intimidate me just flying close and not leaving and every once in a while trying to fly up my shorts or getting hung in my hair. It would really suck if 300 were doing that.
Cheers
gww
GWW there is a link to my website in my profile, have him give a shout next time he is here. Love your state and used to go to MO often on the bike when I lived in IL many moons back. Sure is a purty place with plenty of good fishing, but you got ticks :shocked: Just look at a bush and they are on ya in summer....
nugget
I dress for success. I don't wear a belt or socks and my shirt is usually a size or two too bigg. I don't have too much problim with tics. This year was one of the worst. I think I found 4 all year. It might be that I am old and taste bad.
When I was young we fished and camped the rivers. Now I just go to a lake (not mine) behind my house.
I used to ride my bike to the bars in IL with a couple of guys I worked with back when I worked in st louis.
I have never been to arizona. I lived in oklahoma for a year and indiana for almost four years. I have lived in MO almost my whole life and not just MO but out in the boonies. I drove an hour and fifteen minutes one way to work for 26 years.
You look like you are having fun in life and thats a blessing. Me too.
Guess I will let this thread get back on track.
gww
Why? Maybe we should start a string about getting to know each other. We're all over the world, with a common interest in bees. Our differences and our similarities might be interesting, so long as we respect each others' (at a loss for the proper word here-- boundaries? Feelings? -- help, please).
Dallas
I have found in life that even poeple that I dissagree with on many things usually have some trait that I admire and wish I had. I read all the new threads that come up wether political or on gardining or what ever. I do my best (which I am sure is not that good) to remember those good things when I am finaly drawn into some kind of discussion. I always figure that I have been helped more then I help by a lot of strangers that I am sure I would like if given a better chance. I don't know what my join date was (if you knew me you would know I am not much of a joiner). But I have been taking my time trying to get to know you guys and feel inriched so far. Even if I am about the only democrat here :wink:.
I get off topic cause I can not help myself.
Cheers
gww
I did 2 removals today. I did NOT turn down the 760 dollars. You folks can do what you want, but I think I provide a rare service that just anyone can't do. I get paid well for it. One had tried 5 cans of raid, so it cost them an extra hundred.
I do not charge for swarms.
Swarms are free and hell I have even vacuumed a swarm on Saturday for no charge but if I have to light my smoker and its not for friends , family, or there is some suspicion they are "my bees" and a swarm that escaped people are offered a flat rate for up to 3 hrs then an hourly rate additional. Most people understand time is money and when they see what goes into a removal hey become fans for life and a satisfied customer is the BEST form of advertising ;-)
Quote from: Nugget Shooter on June 30, 2016, 06:59:34 PM
looks like this....
I would look at dismantling the saw (remove it from the tank). If the bees are in the saw the hive is too small but it the bees are in the tank they are worth getting. There will be holes in the tank that could make perfect entrances. Those panels in the front might be doors or drawers that give you access to the tank to cut out the comb. Unfortunately you might destroy the queen and a lot of comb trying to get them open. A hole saw would make an entrance in the tank for better mounting of a trap out screen. Then you would have to calk up the entrance they are using now.