Plywood hive components

Started by JB, March 19, 2008, 01:18:07 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

JB

Is there any chance the chemicals used to make the plywood can get into the honey or hurt the bees?

CBEE

Standard plywood I would say no. Some exterior grade plywood just uses a waterproof type glue to put the plys together and would not be a problem BUT Pressure treated exterior YES, the pressure treatment chemical could get into the honey and possibly kill your bees.

bassman1977

This was discussed to some level in this thread.

http://forum.beemaster.com/index.php?topic=7339.0

QuoteSome exterior grade plywood just uses a waterproof type glue to put the plys together and would not be a problem BUT Pressure treated exterior YES, the pressure treatment chemical could get into the honey and possibly kill your bees.

There are reputable bee equipment manufacturers (without looking, Mann Lake I believe is one of them) who sell treated migratory covers.  I can't believe they would be selling them if it was harmful to your bees or could get into your honey in anyway.
(\__/)
(='.'=)
(''')_(''')

JB

The glue is what I am worried about, from what I have read most plywood glues contain formaldehyde. Not talking pressure treated stuff just plain old plywood. I would like to make a cover like Mr. Bush shows on his site, but not if there is a chance of it getting into the honey. Thanks

pdmattox

I have seen 1/4 plywood used to make four frame nucs and nothing happed to those bees or any of the others that were run through them. plywood is usally used for tops and bottoms and if you are concered let it sit out side to air out.

dlmarti

Exterior grade plywood (but not the dipped stuff), uses phenol formaldehyde glues, which do not out gas.

Quote from: EcoDesign FoundationThe EcoDesign Foundation 5 cautions that glues used in plywood manufacture can have emissions which are potential health hazards. They call this 'outgassing'. Interior-grade plywoods contain urea formaldehyde glues which outgas at room temperature, while the phenol formaldehyde glues used in exterior grade plywood do not. The Foundation says that many architects, therefore, specify exterior grades of ply for interior use.

Dick Allen

Much of my woodenware is made of plywood as I used to get throwaway scrap pieces from work before I retired. The bees have been quite happy with their homes (except, of course, when I open them up and pester the inhabitants  :-D ). The honey tastes good, too.

qa33010

    I use plywood for inner covers and outer covers.  Mainly because of the weight.  No problems.
Everyone said it couldn't be done. But he with a chuckle replied, "I won't be one to say it is so, until I give it a try."  So he buckled right in with a trace of a grin.  If he had a worry he hid it and he started to sing as he tackled that thing that couldn't be done, and he did it.  (unknown)

CBEE

Bassman
There is more than one type of treatment used. Not all of them are non-toxic. I would agree that if they are selling hive parts made of plywood they are not treated with anything that would affect bees or honey. Someone that walks into home depot and buys a sheet of treated plywood or lumber without checking out what chemicals were used may be putting something into their hive they dont want there.

bassman1977

No debate.

For curiosity's sake, I'm going to contact them and see what it is treated with.  I'll report my findings.
(\__/)
(='.'=)
(''')_(''')

bassman1977

QuoteFor curiosity's sake, I'm going to contact them and see what it is treated with.  I'll report my findings.

That was easy.  The lady that answered said it was arsenic free, food grade wood preservative.  She didn't have the exact name for me.
(\__/)
(='.'=)
(''')_(''')

JB

Thanks everyone, I will see what I can find in my area.

CBEE

  That was easy.  The lady that answered said it was arsenic free, food grade wood preservative.  She didn't have the exact name for me.

Thats good to hear. CCA is still used as a pressure treating wood preservative. The " A " stands for arsenic  :shock:

limyw

Water proof plywood did not cause any problem to my bee and honey. Bees would fan away unwanted gases emitted from board.
lyw

buzzbee

Remember one other thing too: Homes are put together more airtight than a beehive with many different chemical components.Pvc plumbing,vinyl flooring.stained trims,liquid nails,house wrap,fiberglass,gypsum,and many more.Bees often propolize the wood inside too,sealing the outgassing to the exterior.